T/HARACM 0007-2023 基于循证医学PICO模型的中医医案评价工具

!"#!!!"#"

""#""$

!!!!"!!!#!!!$

$!%&'&"("""%"#"#&

%&'()*)!"*+,-.))/

0123

+,-./-0123022.2405-610123-."713898:861;138:861;-.;-989<-986

23)!"*:268.248,1683;8=<-986:861;138

#"#&="#=!&45#"#&="#=!&67

89:.);<=>?@45

.A#$BCDBC

书

!!"#$#%&!!!""#!#$

!!!"

!"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

#"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!$%!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

"!&$'#()*!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

#!+,-./!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$!0123!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

%!4(56!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

78)9!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

书

!!"#$#%&!!!""#!#$

#!!$

!!:)*;<&'"(!)!#"*"*$=>?2@AB!C!DE%=>?)*FGH-IJ&B&F&.

IJ'

KLM:)*FNOPQRSTUVW':)*FXYZH[\]^_VWF`a'

:)*bcdefghijklmnopqr'

:)*IJst%cdfghuvCwxygz(cdfghuv({|}~gzCgvf€(c

defgz(‚fghuvxygz(cdefghijz(cdeƒ„…†gz)cde†‡gz*(

ˆ‰Šfgz(‹Œe†‡gz(ffg‡vzfghŽf€(‘fghuvxy’“gz'

:)*”•IJ–%—˜/(™š›(œ’(žŸ(

i¡($¢(£¤¥(œ¦(§¨©(ª«¬(

­®¯(°±²(³´µ(¶·(°¸¹(º¥»(ª¼½(¾l¿(ÀÁÂ(Àm}(°Ã(Ä)Å(ÆÇÈ(

™É(ÊË'

"

!!"#$#%&!!!""#!#$

%!!$

!!Ì\ÍÎÏÐfghXÑF¥Ò”Ó'ԏ$fÕfÖ!×zØÙklfghÌ\ÎÏXÑF

MÚ&+ÛÜH±fghÝÞ(–(ßà-áâãàäGåÐfghÌ\XÑFØæç+èéfghÌ

\ÎÏêëìíî'–(ßàÐgïðñFòóßà-ôóßàFGå+õÌ\F:öÐ÷'ø

^FXù-4(+Ðáâú(ûü&ýnþ-01Fÿ!'ß"g5Ж(ßàF,#?$-'

,+,-.-ÐáâijF%:•&+3'=>?(GH?(()?*+,'-.+/+,-.•&H±g50

123+S012g5F34'(&$'(1ú'01+ë25GH?67E8g59:n;"<v=>

-=>g5Ž?ö?@*+=Ag5ˆBCD-÷'ø^Eù+ÐXùg5÷'ø^FØæ'F!ë

G+HIXYfgg59:äØJKF=>+PLHI±Mfgg5F0123'

ëNOò–-&FPQ+nRáâûü-áâ‡iF>S'-wT'+UìðV‡v%WXYZ

F###fgvijÏ[+ÍÏ"<,X\–(ßàfgß"g5F÷'ø^X2Íáâ1]0^)ZF

_>`%/"!0$%"1.ZFa`–%—˜/*-bcd+34efghU2'fgg5ij+ijò5E8(5

6èÝ(ö'):E8<(klfgg5~G*%mY+n(opqVìrs<()934tu(vw<

ûx'ãà(VìˆByz*"<+Gå{|i}ÍÞú+~Õ^%ـúgv+,-.‚Ff

gg50123'ƒ„…(†‡g5lˆ014(+lˆ23‰Š‹~:0123'

:0123ÐwòŒÿ€úgv+,-.‹•&Ífgg5+'•&Ž401=+(.

‡(.'01"<lˆfgg5ö‡0^‘…F0123+ëg5Fáâûün(͇i2@(n;

A-’c'

:0123bٓ”(•ijFF(ûü–—(ßà*-&F˜™+U3ó1šÿ!f+›Gå1

œžŸ.':0123RÍfgg5õ

01=>åp(':0123è¡(Ùfgg50

1+R¢(Ùáâü£P¤¥šè¡'¦lw§ij'

#

!!"#$#%&!!!""#!#$

&'()*+'(%),-./**0

1234

%!56

:)*¨.©äØ+,-./+˜S©%ـúgv+,-.‚Ffgg50E=>(01*

ª+n;©«P4(56'

:)*†(Ù¬5(­25(®5F¯°fgg5(±²'

:)*†(Ù³¯ªgüZH(‡iz´(R*zµ*stFáâgï(‡i–¶(·¸(ijï

*¹ºfg)9(fgg5(fg€ú(fgáâ(klfgßàÌ\(fhÏhUfgÌ\ÎÏ*"X

Fij'

#!758%9:;

:)*»'&$'#()*'

$!<=>?@

d¼+,-./†(Ù:)*'

$)%

()*+!*+,-*./*0123*-4*-,/,.*+56&

½€úFgv'

A%€úgvno©gvú(ÝÞ-1¾¿ÀF+.Á3'€úgvFÂ^ÞFÀÐ%åÝFä9þÄÙú

R9B+ú9aBbR9ÿ!Ä.'

$)#

'(%),-!'(%)47-*8

€úgvÝÅdH±‡vÆÓF衁Ç'ȁ‚É.gv):fFÊË+S.áâãàf̂

ÍÎ+•&ij%+)2324567839"2:3;5<=*###Ï+.бF–ô.,)897<:><97839"<?23@4:<*###P¤¥

šÑÒÓ@*.-)A3=26:8@39"A397:35*###Ž<çÑ(ÙÔÕFP¤¥š..)347A3=<*###GÖ'

$)$

/**0!4*-,/289*/79-37:;92-,;,7.28%<,.*3*4*-,/,.*

gìtån(fgÝ<"hûüбF×1ØÙ)

A%%fgg5ÚÛëûÜ(±5(à5(ò5(Ý5("5*'

A#%Þß©gìáâàú(M<(á"((hFáâßà-âãÿ!'

$)&

BC&DEF!123,/,.:7942;,7.7:=2;,*.;

&DGH

ϕF%:ž'

A%äåijæk('_(oïçèé(êë(ìíîž(ïð(Üñ(2@st(òó*'

!

!!"#$#%&!!!""#!#$

$)'

IJKL!+,3,;;,4*

ϕôûFõÀ'

$)(

MN!/<,*:/74=82,.;

kÏ•ôûFƒ”•Föî(óUõA÷õÀ'

$)"

OPEF!,./,-*./*

PQRS

ϕ¹I±”ôûõF±XÑø?ž+/©{бFùøUõXÑúû'

A%%ijϕX±F3óõÀ(ü,+I±Fýþ+RSFÿ-Ñ!-)"#$(%&(Ÿ('(()*ø?**'

A#%w+;<X±õÀF,„-.lˆsÆ+ijX±!F,/öî(X±„Nw01o2Föî+/UöîF'

ö(!B*.öîU2õÛ3Ñ45/U2õo2ÏFöî.±ø?'6&ý)"78ø?Í9(f(:Fø

?(l$!„Fø?**U±ý{)";h(<:**(Û=F-&*'

$)

TU!/7.3;,;>;,7.

–óU,>?@-„>‰A%mY´FBGH-ïÝCSYäŽD.F+''

$)*

PVTU!=2;<787?,/28-,2;<*3,3

ZóE„)FFø?Go…HóöF$%Ÿo2E„I‰()FI-F+'

$)%!

JWRS!-,2?.73,32.-;9*2;4*.;=97/*33

ϕϱ„ä.Jôû!´K“ÿFûxÍLüž+;õÀ-.lˆsÆ'

A%ijU2áMNÿOOCP+GQ"2.Nÿ2Rûx+S-GÞÐTU.ßÿOOLü+/U(hFž)"

hVkÛ((‡(õÀ-(hFWX**+Lü£QUÞ4*'

$)%%

XYZ!/>99*.;3@4=;743

[\Z

ϕôûõo2F´'YZ-[†F[2'

A%\•õ+ŽÏ•I”é]^F#$(_`(Ÿ(uab*žclˆsÆ'

$)%#

]J!,.3=*/;,7.

ŒÿdefgϕFh(i((B(jk(lom(an$oÝ*FpHø?'

$)%$

^J!8,3;*.,.?2.-34*88,.?

g¸Œÿqe-re©{bϕ±óXoF¯RpHst-)uFwRûx"<'

A%ijqst-r)uv"XFPQ'

$)%&

_J!,.A>,9@

gïŒÿsÆϕÑwû•+©{бFXï(XÑ(Lüßÿ(2Uö(õ

Íб'ØFž+/

ûgбF"<'

$)%'

`J!=>83*=28=2;,7.

g•(xÑxyŽÏ•FÝ-³ñ+.ÑäØDtlˆz({(;(|+pŒÿxFzeUϕF

"

!!"#$#%&!!!""#!#$

Þ4îB+©{±(ûgбF"<'

$)%(

abc!=23;4*-,/28<,3;79@

ijϕgh}“îž(б~(̱~(¤€KR~(x+L~(‚F~($mÑhmÿ»

~*'

A%"'ÿ»~+Blw§sÆMßÿ»FmV)"hm($m(ƒ„**+/Uÿ»F3óž+ijÿ»õF[2

UõA÷õÀ(Û3Ñý{-&*'

$)%"

Pd!=2;<7?*.,/:2/;793

…†–óE„䎇ˆŸ#IбFÿ-'

$)%)

Pe!=2;<7?*.*3,3

бXï(XÑ(ø?UõGÖFZÝ'

$)%*

/*fPg!-,3*23*.24*37:;92-,;,7.28%<,.*3*4*-,/,.*

Pg

ԏfgÝÞ-áâ1¾´FŽVÐ±:ö‰j'F[u'

A%fgбkЎNR"°T±-&´#XFVÐ±+Íùø&ýF:ö‰j+&.©Ð±Fáâ³ÿ!U

ä4Fú*øé+Š‹©õŽNVÐ±F±-(±t(±Z(áâ+UŒq(¤„*F&ý'F%:Â^'

$)#!

/*)hg!=2;;*9..24*37:;92-,;,7.28%<,.*3*4*-,/,.*

)-

fgŽÐ±ÿ!f–óŽ,…Ž-BûUõÞ4FxGQ+Ўб01'±Ý‘øÍ+.

ϕh)ö+p'Þ4F’õ‰j'

A%,fgú*k-Š‹©õŽNVú*F±-(±t(±'Uõ…(E„()FBû*F&ý'Â^+Ў®!

,…Ž-Bû´@oF’õx+cÐfgSMLüÿB(“(ƒ”®[+"<•Ñûü#éF%:S'

$)#%

Wi!;<*92=*>;,/=9,./,=8*

Lüб\–½€F%:ÿB'

A%fgLBi—L±FÿB-"<+"%I±,€+L±˜:+…L)™•š¿(›•œ¿**+ÞL)™-™((-

(**+þBL=+ýBL:+=:?L+ž…Ÿ+

œ¡š+-õ-ü-–¢£*'

$)##

Wjkl!;9*2;4*.;

LüF3ó"<'

A%fgLüx1;LüWXREëLL(PLvu°.;“(Fx1REëmÝF(?vF(ïmF((hF(tå

Fu°'"%hmü<)¤h(¥¦**+§¨ü<)©§ü<(ª@¨ü<**+è«ü<)¬­ü<(è®ü<

**+LLü<)¯°ü<(±%ü<**+#$ü<)$ü(h²ü<**+Mü<)Ÿü<(t³ü<**+´ü<

)µ¶ü<(·#ü<***'

$)#$

Wjmn!;9*2;4*.;2.28@3,3

§ŽLüx1F…¸ÿ-+Gåϕ±(Lü"<FgvÿÝlˆF¹º(â8Í~G*'

$)#&

op!/7.;923;

qrop

Ž<-ãàU?wijŽkYlˆ'

A%ÔÕ?w“ãŽk/ðñNŽ<+fg[?P¤¥š™4Ñ~”ãàF=Fij"<'

#

!!"#$#%&!!!""#!#$

$)#'

stuv!/8,.,/287>;/74*

ßÿw.õÀ+NR}“ÆÓ(Lü"5-gvP¤´»¼FáâGQ'

A%%áâGÖÐ01ϕТ¹NRLü"<f“½F='

A#%ij¾'pXöXï¿(ÀÁ¿(òzõÀ(ö‡‰ŠÂÃç*'

&!1234

:23ij#DE%%ـúgv+,-.‚Ffgg501230.[)Ú[!*(g5*ª7<

[)Ú["*(fgg5•&)0EZ*PŠ)Ú[#*'

w%!&'()*+'(%),-./**012341?w

+,-.ifgg5•&

@EE]ÄE

j•&)0EZ*

!)”]PQ6)0E*

"%E)nU(3'.Z’R*

"!E),öî(óUõA÷õÀ-ÕëƊ*

”]PQ6(Å"!E),öî(óUõA÷õÀ-ÇÈ(3ó*

dö6")Ådö6)0E*

"%E)nU(3'.Z’R*

"!E),ÉÊÆˋûÌÄF®döî-ÕëƊ*

"!E),ÉÊÆˋûÌÄF®döî-ÇÈ(3ó*

!)ϕ%:9:A)!E*

"!E)nU(3'.Z’R*

")ôûõÀA)!E*

"!E)nU(3'.Z’R*

ϕ%:9:A(#)±kA)#E*

ôûõÀA(±"!E)nU(3'.Z’R.Ñfg'õ/ú*("ú@,±k-

kA(ú‚A͏N±cR+",uÎ˱(aÏ

¤ú-**

+.ϕ""E)˜Sûx±k+Ɗ[u*

)+*$)ú‚A)#E*

)#$E*"!E)nU(3'.Z’R.ÑE8±-(L<õnUcRÄE*

""E)'˜SFàúÞLÿ!ØÙ*

!)ϕX±ž)±!ßÿ*A)$E*

""E)nU(3'.Z’R*

"!E),!-(X±õÀ(±ùøÿ!*-ÕëƊ*

"!E),!-(X±õÀ(±ùøÿ!*-ÇÈ(3ó*

")ûLßÿA)$E*

ϕX±žA""E)nU(3'.Z’R*

)±!ßÿ*("!E),ghûü((hU£Q*-ÕëƊ*

ûLßÿA("!E),ghûü((hU£Q*-ÇÈ(3ó*

gh~A)A%«˜S[uëÐJX±„’Ñôû+RÄ$E+«[S˜S

lÒghûüßÿB;0E•,0E*

#)gh~A)$E*

""E)nU(3'.Z’R*

"!E),gh}“îž(б~(̱~*-ÕëƊ*

"!E),gh}“îž(б~(̱~*-ÇÈ(3ó*

$

!!"#$#%&!!!""#!#$

w%!&'()*+'(%),-./**012341?w)÷*

+,-.ifgg5•&

@EE]ÄE

j•&)0EZ*

б±-(±ZE8;)"*E*

"!*E)nU(3'.Z’R*

"!E),±-(±ZE8-ÕëƊ*

б±-(±Z

"$E),±-(±ZE8-ÇÈ(3ó+Gå3ó±*

E8;

"!E),±-(±ZE8-#(56(

ö*ŽÔE8*

""E),±-(±ZE8-3'RÓ@'*

""E)g•.~GR;ÔÕF&ý*

Lüx16)!%E*

LüP

!*E)nU(3'.Z’R*

¤"Ç"

""E)3óLü"ÇÕëƊ+˜S,"k(hmçÑÖt*

),*Lüx16

PQ-*

)%*E*

"#E)3óLü"ÇÇÈ(3ó+˜S,hm(‡Ñ3óx<*

PQ-*

LüE8;)!%E*

"!*E)nU(3'.Z’R*

"!E),g•ŽLü"ÇF¹º(â8Í~G*-ÕëƊ*

LüE8;

"!E)3óLü"ÇÇÈ(3ó+˜SLüõÀ**

""E)3óLü"ÇG屝Ž4¹º*

"!E)g•.~GR;ÔÕF&ý*

Ž<ç

Ž<)ðñŽ<)ðñŽ<*6)BE*

)-*

Ž<*6"BE)ϕðñLü!„Ž<+nU(3'.Z’RÄE*

)BE*

ϕáâGÖ6)!*E*

"$E)nU(3'.Z’R*

áâü£

"#E),ôû„äØöî(9:"”•öî‘×(pXö(бØ

).*ϕáâGÖ6

Xž(˜SLüõÀ*-ÕëƊ*

)!*E*

"#E),ôû„äØöî(9:"”•öî‘×(pXö(бØ

Xž(˜SLüõÀ*-ÇÈ(3ó*

À•&Z~E)C#*%

g5*ª%

~E)C*%

!!A%%:)*/ÙnRfgg5€úúö‡+BÚfëە0>B'0E/ÈZ,'6-U,ÇÈB-ë